Selective use of drains in thyroid surgery.

Overview

In the past, it was generally advised that every patient undergoing thyroid surgery have a drain placed because of the fear of post-operative hematoma. In the past 9 years, we have performed 400 thyroidectomies. For the first 6 years, we drained the operative site in most of thyroid procedures. However, it was apparent from our experience that drains had very little effect on the prevention of post-operative hematoma or of seroma. As a matter of fact, all four patients who required re-exploration in our initial series had drains in place. As a result of this experience over the past 3 years, during which time we have performed 150 thyroidectomies, we have used drains selectively. The indications for draining the thyroid bed have been the presence of a large dead space, operation for a large substernal goiter, and subtotal thyroidectomy for either large, multinodular goiter or for Graves' disease. Thus, among 150 recent thyroidectomies, we have drained only 35, and avoided drains in 115 patients. Though this is not a prospective study, we found no difference in the overall outcome whether drains were employed or not. Most patients who had no drains were ready for discharge within 24-48 hours of surgery. Since it may be difficult to perform a randomized prospective trial examining the use of drains in thyroid surgery, we propose that drains should be utilized only selectively for thyroid surgery.